In space applications, more and more organic polymers (adhesives, resins, paints and packaging of electronic devices) are used for their performance, their cost and their flexibility for the design of future satellites. This is especially true in the New Space era, using Off-The-Shelf devices with rarely well-known materials. Outgassed products of these materials under vacuum is a major cause of dramatic flux losses for contaminated optical devices, especially in the UV range. Thus, material outgassing must be studied and better controlled, during all the phases of satellite integration. Fluorescence hyperspectral imaging is a powerful technique for both locating and analyzing materials: their fluorescence spectra can be interpreted as a signature of their physicochemical composition. However, common commercial hyperspectral instruments do not meet the specifications required for such applications: very high sensitivity (SNR < 10000), wide spectral band (ideally 250-1000 nm), integrated multi-wavelength UV excitation and spectral range resolution of about 3 nm. In addition, classical optical design with diopters has to be avoided to prevent chromaticism, which is not compatible with wide spectral bandwidth, especially in UV range. These constraints led us to develop a new dedicated optical design, with the specificity of being catoptric on axis. Therefore, we built a first transportable instrument. In this paper, we present the evaluation of the characteristics of this instrument, its real performance and examples of measurements on flight models. A new version has been designed, using laser sources to limit exposure time of examined materials as much as possible, as they may be degraded under UV light.
KEYWORDS: Diffusion, Physics, Chemical species, Data modeling, Chemical analysis, Temperature metrology, Standards development, Mass spectrometry, Epoxies, Data processing
Progress was performed recently on the separation and characterization of the chemical species outgassed by space materials, relying on the assessment of thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) peaks by mass spectrometry (MS). A companion communication reports on this experimental technique and the first level processing of these MS data, which often allows determining which are the outgassed species, and their MS spectra. This communication focusses more on the second analysis step, i.e. the study of the MS data acquired during the initial outgassing phase. Ancient simpler outgassing analyses based on total mass measurements only, most of the time on quartz crystal microbalances (QCMs), cannot realistically determine the separate contribution of different species, even though some models consider the contribution of several species, which are indeed more “mathematical species” than physical ones. In contrast, this new approach, also taking into account the MS measurements during the outgassing, and known species spectra (from the TGA/MS analysis done previously), allows a more realistic determination of the contribution of each real chemical species to the total outgassing. Even though results are not yet final and perfect, measured outgassing fluxes from several species and materials are presented. Their physical analysis, through comparison and fit by diffusion or other possible outgassing laws are also presented. At this level, they clearly point to diffusion laws, rather than to any other outgassing law, although not necessarily always Fickian diffusion. This method was applied to typical US or European outgassing approaches, with either isothermal ASTM-1559 outgassing tests or multi-temperature VBQC-type tests.
Well-established procedures for the characterization of contamination during outgassing usually involve total mass measurements through quartz crystal microbalance (QCM). Recently, the addition of mass spectrometry (MS) measurements to these data has become more common. The combination of both high sensitivity QCM and MS data may lead to a better understanding of the physics taking place during outgassing contamination processes. The way to do so is to complement the basic measurements of total mass loss on QCMs by the identification of each species and the quantitative determination of each species contribution. In a first characterization step, the thermogravimetric analysis of contaminants deposited on QCMs allows a partial species separation that helps exploiting mass spectrometry data. In return, these data permit a finer species separation. The key to these measurements is to obtain sufficient signal to noise ratio in the mass spectrometer. Though outgassing of space materials is not done the same way in Europe (multi-temperature steps, ECSS-Q-TM-70-52A) and in the US (isothermal, ASTM E-1559-09), both tests could be used to perform a first species separation, as reported here. Most species outgassed by a few common materials were identified (and quantified) through TGA and MS coupling. As reported in a companion paper, the knowledge of these species’ spectra then allows the analysis of the MS data during the initial outgassing phase, determining the quantitative outgassing of each species and leading to the improved comprehension of the physical laws ruling outgassing.
The numerical assessment of in-flight contamination is a global process, which needs consistent numerical processing of elementary ground tests and global modeling of in-orbit situations. If the traditional physical approach of Europe is followed, both sides must make use of consistent physical models, and upgrade them consistently. This article presents recent progress performed at ONERA, in collaboration with CNES, in this respect. For this physical approach, elementary material outgassing tests aim at characterizing each chemical species independently, based on TGA / MS coupling for in situ characterization. Processing large data sets of mass peaks versus time, and interpreting them as resulting from a few outgassed chemical species, each one with its own mass spectrum, requires heavy computations and smart algorithms. The first results shown here are very promising. QCM and mass spec data acquired during TGAs where fitted with very convincing models for deposit reemission and mass spectra for the reemitted species that were identified with database spectra. This makes us confident in the next step consisting in similarly interpreting outgassing QCM + MS measurements in term of discriminated species, although they are all outgassed simultaneously in that case.
Contamination modeling has struggled with the challenge of species separation. Without the capabiliity to physically identify the chemical nature of contaminants and their contributions, the realistic correspondence between a chosen model and its underlying physics is very difficult to demonstrate. With the development of TGA/MS coupling experimental techniques and specific data treatments, a species separation was achieved on the ScotchWeld EC2216 adhesive. After a detailed exposure of the species separation need, this paper presents the experimental facility and the numerical procedure to effectively get contaminants identification and differentiate their contribution in a mixture.
Space instruments such as solar arrays, radiators, or optics can be strongly impacted by molecular contaminants outgassed from spacecraft materials. For optics, transmittance and reflectance performances could indeed be modified by the deposit of contaminants. We report the transmittance measurements and predictions in the ultraviolet–visible–near-infrared range of contaminated optics from the outgassing of a mixture of two common materials used in space industry: EC2216 material (epoxy compound) and RTVS691 material (silicone compound). The Swanepoel model, commonly used in many fields, was employed for the first time in such conditions to easily and quickly predict transmittance. Transmittance was fully recovered at 20°C; a decontamination plan could be based on heating at this temperature at least during a duration depending on the silicone/epoxy contaminants layer thickness.
KEYWORDS: Diffusion, Molecules, Contamination, Physics, Data modeling, Mathematical modeling, Chemical species, Ultraviolet radiation, Chemical reactions, Mass spectrometry
Contamination modeling in Europe has long been based on physical mechanisms, such as desorption. However other physical mechanisms, such as diffusion, evaporation or mixing effects exist. These alternative mechanisms were experimentally evaluated and modelled. It was yet observed that, without an experimental capability to reliably separate the (re)emitted chemical species, it is very difficult to determine whether the modeling and its underlying physical mechanisms are representative of reality, or simply a mathematical fit of reality. This is the reason why in the last years emphasis was put on the experimental separation of species, mostly through TGA/MS coupling. This paper presents a review of these efforts and promising results on species separation to reach a really physical modeling of outgassing, deposition/reemission and UV synergy.
Access to the requested content is limited to institutions that have purchased or subscribe to SPIE eBooks.
You are receiving this notice because your organization may not have SPIE eBooks access.*
*Shibboleth/Open Athens users─please
sign in
to access your institution's subscriptions.
To obtain this item, you may purchase the complete book in print or electronic format on
SPIE.org.
INSTITUTIONAL Select your institution to access the SPIE Digital Library.
PERSONAL Sign in with your SPIE account to access your personal subscriptions or to use specific features such as save to my library, sign up for alerts, save searches, etc.