Wafer Plane Inspection (WPI) is an inspection mode on the KLA-Tencor TeraScaTM platform that uses the high signalto-
noise ratio images from the high numerical aperture microscope, and then models the entire lithographic process to
enable defect detection on the wafer plane[1]. This technology meets the needs of some advanced mask manufacturers
to identify the lithographically-significant defects while ignoring the other non-lithographically-significant defects. WPI
accomplishes this goal by performing defect detection based on a modeled image of how the mask features would
actually print in the photoresist. There are several advantages to this approach: (1) the high fidelity of the images
provide a sensitivity advantage over competing approaches; (2) the ability to perform defect detection on the wafer plane
allows one to only see those defects that have a printing impact on the wafer; (3) the use of modeling on the lithographic
portion of the flow enables unprecedented flexibility to support arbitrary illumination profiles, process-window
inspection in unit time, and combination modes to find both printing and non-printing defects. WPI is proving to be a
valuable addition to the KLA-Tencor detection algorithm suite.
The modeling portion of WPI uses a single resist threshold as the final step in the processing. This has been shown to be
adequate on several advanced customer layers, but is not ideal for all layers. Actual resist chemistry has complicated
processes including acid and base-diffusion and quench that are not consistently well-modeled with a single resist
threshold. We have considered the use of an advanced resist model for WPI, but rejected it because the burdensome
requirements for the calibration of the model were not practical for reticle inspection. This paper describes an alternative
approach that allows for a "soft" resist threshold to be applied that provides a more robust solution for the most
challenging processes. This approach is just finishing beta testing with a customer developing advanced node designs.
Wafer Plane Inspection (WPI) is a novel approach to inspection, developed to enable high inspectability on fragmented
mask features at the optimal defect sensitivity. It builds on well-established high resolution inspection capabilities to
complement existing manufacturing methods. The production of defect-free photomasks is practical today only because
of informed decisions on the impact of defects identified. The defect size, location and its measured printing impact can
dictate that a mask is perfectly good for lithographic purposes. This inspection - verification - repair loop is timeconsuming
and is predicated on the fact that detectable photomask defects do not always resolve or matter on wafer.
This paper will introduce and evaluate an alternative approach that moves the mask inspection to the wafer plane. WPI
uses a high NA inspection of the mask to construct a physical mask model. This mask model is used to create the mask
image in the wafer plane. Finally, a threshold model is applied to enhance sensitivity to printing defects. WPI essentially
eliminates the non-printing inspection stops and relaxes some of the pattern restrictions currently placed on incoming
photomask designs. This paper outlines the WPI technology and explores its application to patterns and substrates
representative of 32nm designs. The implications of deploying Wafer Plane Inspection will be discussed.
High Resolution reticle inspection is well-established as a proven, effective, and efficient means of detecting yieldlimiting
mask defects as well as defects which are not immediately yield-limiting yet can enable manufacturing process
improvements. Historically, RAPID products have enabled detection of both classes of these defects. The newlydeveloped
Wafer Plane Inspection (WPI) detector technology meets the needs of some advanced mask manufacturers to
identify the lithographically-significant defects while ignoring the other non-lithographically-significant defects. Wafer
Plane Inspection accomplishes this goal by performing defect detection based on a modeled image of how the mask
features would actually print in the photoresist. This has the effect of reducing sensitivity to non-printing defects while
enabling higher sensitivity focused in high MEEF areas where small reticle defects still yield significant printing defects
on wafers.
This approach has several important features. The ability to ignore non-printing defects and to apply additional effective
sensitivity in high MEEF areas enables advanced node development. In addition, the modeling allows the inclusion of
important polarization effects that occur in the resist for high NA operation. This allows for the results to better match
wafer print results compared to alternate approaches. Finally, the simulation easily allows for the application of
arbitrary illumination profiles. With this approach, users of WPI can make use of unique or custom scanner illumination
profiles. This allows the more precise modeling of profiles without inspection system hardware modification or loss of
company intellectual property.
A previous paper [1] introduced WPI in D:D mode. This paper examines the operation and results for WPI in
Die:Database mode.
Readiness of new mask defect inspection technology is one of the key enablers for insertion & transition of the next
generation technology from development into production. High volume production in mask shops and wafer fabs
demands a reticle inspection system with superior sensitivity complemented by a low false defect rate to ensure fast
turnaround of reticle repair and defect disposition (W. Chou et al 2007).
Wafer Plane Inspection (WPI) is a novel approach to mask defect inspection, complementing the high resolution
inspection capabilities of the TeraScanHR defect inspection system. WPI is accomplished by using the high resolution
mask images to construct a physical mask model (D. Pettibone et al 1999). This mask model is then used to create the
mask image in the wafer aerial plane. A threshold model is applied to enhance the inspectability of printing defects. WPI
can eliminate the mask restrictions imposed on OPC solutions by inspection tool limitations in the past. Historically,
minimum image restrictions were required to avoid nuisance inspection stops and/or subsequent loss of sensitivity to
defects. WPI has the potential to eliminate these limitations by moving the mask defect inspections to the wafer plane.
This paper outlines Wafer Plane Inspection technology, and explores the application of this technology to advanced
reticle inspection. A total of twelve representative critical layers were inspected using WPI die-to-die mode. The results
from scanning these advanced reticles have shown that applying WPI with a pixel size of 90nm (WPI P90) captures all
the defects of interest (DOI) with low false defect detection rates. In validating CD predictions, the delta CDs from WPI
are compared against Aerial Imaging Measurement System (AIMS), where a good correlation is established between
WPI and AIMSTM.
High Resolution reticle inspection is well-established as a proven, effective, and efficient means of detecting yield-limiting
mask defects as well as defects which are not immediately yield-limiting yet can enable manufacturing process
improvements. Historically, RAPID products have enabled detection of both classes of these defects. The newly-developed
Wafer Plane Inspection (WPI) detector technology meets the needs of some advanced mask manufacturers to
identify the lithographically-significant defects while ignoring the other non-lithographically-significant defects. Wafer
Plane Inspection accomplishes this goal by performing defect detection based on a modeled image of how the mask
features would actually print in the photoresist. This has the effect of reducing sensitivity to non-printing defects while
enabling higher sensitivity focused in high MEEF areas where small reticle defects still yield significant printing defects
on wafers.
WPI is a new inspection mode that has been developed by KLA-Tencor and is currently under test with multiple
customers. It employs the same transmitted and reflected-light high-resolution images as the industry-standard high-resolution
inspections, but with much more sophisticated processing involved. A rigorous mask pattern recovery
algorithm is used to convert the transmitted and reflected light images into a modeled representation of the reticle.
Lithographic modeling of the scanner is then used to generate an aerial image of the mask. This is followed by resist
modeling to determine the exposure of the photoresist. The defect detectors are then applied on this photoresist plane so
that only printing defects are detected. Note that no hardware modifications to the inspection system are required to
enable this detector. The same tool will be able to perform both our standard High Resolution inspections and the Wafer
Plane Inspection detector.
This approach has several important features. The ability to ignore non-printing defects and to apply additional effective
sensitivity in high MEEF areas enables advanced node development. In addition, the modeling allows the inclusion of
important polarization effects that occur in the resist for high NA operation. This allows for the results to better match
wafer print results compared to alternate approaches. Finally, the simulation easily allows for the application of
arbitrary illumination profiles. With this approach, users of WPI can make use of unique or custom scanner illumination
profiles. This allows the more precise modeling of profiles without inspection system hardware modification or loss of
company intellectual property.
This paper examines WPI in Die:Die mode. Future work includes a review of Die:Database WPI capability.
Access to the requested content is limited to institutions that have purchased or subscribe to SPIE eBooks.
You are receiving this notice because your organization may not have SPIE eBooks access.*
*Shibboleth/Open Athens users─please
sign in
to access your institution's subscriptions.
To obtain this item, you may purchase the complete book in print or electronic format on
SPIE.org.
INSTITUTIONAL Select your institution to access the SPIE Digital Library.
PERSONAL Sign in with your SPIE account to access your personal subscriptions or to use specific features such as save to my library, sign up for alerts, save searches, etc.